Toothless at 10
celebrations should ideally have marked the tenth anniversary of Panchayati Raj institutions (pris), which are often described as world's largest experiment in decentralised governance. Even Prime Minister (pm) Atal Bihari Vajpayee had wanted the occasion to be commemorated in the winter session of parliament. Instead, the house did not list any business on Panchayati Raj issues for the session and the event passed unnoticed. The reason: the pm himself failed to keep a promise he had made two months back.
He had then given an assurance that some 2.4 lakh panchayats would be further empowered and the constitution amended again to enable the direct flow of funds to these bodies. But the devolutionary process has remained static and hence there is no cause for cheer.
Lost landmark It was on December 22 and 23 that India completed 10 years of adopting pris as local bodies of self-governance through the 73rd and 74th constitutional amendments. "If all political parties agree, the Union ministries of rural development, finance and law will together work out a draft amendment,' Vajpayee had said on October 4, inaugurating a national conference of project directors of district and rural development agencies (drdas) in Delhi. He was referring to proposed constitutional amendments that would facilitate the direct flow of funds from the Centre to pris. They would also make it mandatory for state governments to devolve certain powers to the bodies.
However, according to officials in the Union ministry of rural development, it will be months before the draft amendments are ready. "They are under consideration,' says Babni Lal, joint secretary in charge of Panchayati Raj. This is the only response that can be elicited from the nodal ministry. Lal refuses to divulge details, claiming that it would breach parliament confidentiality.
There is another reason why celebrations have been put on hold. The Union government is likely to miss a deadline set by around three million panchayat leaders to transfer power to them by December 31, 2002. The resolve was made at a national gathering in April this year, where Vajpayee had admitted to the failure in making panchayats effective. He sought suggestions from the leaders to improve the functioning of panchayats. The latter had then given the ultimatum to the government to transfer all constitutionally stipulated powers to them as well as hold elections to panchayat bodies.
"Given the lack of political will to empower people, the government will not be able to meet the deadline,' avers Rajesh Tandon, president of Delhi-based Society for Participatory Research in Asia (pria). He adds: "If the pm so wishes, he can turn around the fate of the panchayats and solve the country's problems faster.'
At a standstill The pain of not moving an inch towards decentralised governance since the 1992 statute amendments racks the entire country (see box: Power shortage ). Various studies confirm that pris remain ineffective due to the lack of commitment of successive governments. Simply put, panchayats have no funds, functions and functionaries.
According to a research by Jean Dreze, an honourary professor with the Delhi School of Economics, in most states the main responsibility of a sarpanch is just to oversee various development programmes. A study of panchayats in 19 states by the National Institute of Rural Development (nird), Hyderabad, shows that parties across the political spectrum are unwilling to delegate power to the pris. The National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution has favoured amendments to devolve financial power to the panchayats. The pm's promise, too, is said to be based on this suggestion.
Though the constitution makes holding of regular panchayat elections mandatory and requires the state governments to transfer powers to these bodies to manage 29 subjects at the village, block and district level, the stipulation is being violated with impunity. The panchayat poll process has been completed in the states only recently
Related Content
- Action against mining leases pending with GSPCB ‘head’
- No pesticide limits prescribed for veggies, fruits sold in State
- Pangolin is most poached species of 2015 in India
- Flexible or toothless?
- Ministry of environment and forests notification cuts down on independent members in wildlife board
- National Board for Wildlife to be toothless