The current pipe-drains-plant strategy is not working. Therefore, more of the same, without reworking its approach, will mean just more money down the drain.
The Yamuna is Delhi's shame. But its pollution management is its government's shame. It cannot be acceptable that we have spent money, time and energy, but have so little.
It is clear also that this changed strategy will have to connect the river and its action plan to the city's water users and waste generators. Sewage management and waste treatment is not only about building sewage plants, but even more about ensuring that we can reuse, recycle and minimise the need for transporting treated and untreated sewage and its disposal.
The fact also is that the Yamuna does not have water for virtually nine months of the year. Delhi impounds Yamuna water for drinking at its entry at Wazirabad. What flows subsequently is only sewage and waste. In other words, the river ceases to exist at Wazirabad. This also means that there is just no water available to dilute the waste. The issue of a basic minimum flow in the river has been discussed time and again, but with water becoming more and more scarce and contested, Delhi's upstream neighbours are reluctant to release water to allow the river's flow. Delhi itself is water-greedy and sucks up each drop released as its share. The river is then left with no option but to become a receptacle for the filth and waste of the city's inhabitants.
In this scenario, Delhi can demand more water; both for its drinking water and to dilute its waste. But this strategy is untenable. The river is needed for its water. But more importantly, it is increasingly made dirty with the waste of all. Its own assimilative capacity is on the decline. With increasingly pollution and little action, the river will never be able to recover. It will be dead.
What can and must be done:
firstly , it will require a shift in thinking so that all sewage that is generated, is trapped and treated. In other words, we cannot afford to distinguish between legal and illegal sewage.
It is only government that can think of people, without sewage. The fact is if there are people, there will be excreta. And if there is excreta, there will be pollution. What we need is to break the sewage drain-hardware approach, so that we can find ways of providing sanitation facilities, as quickly as possible, in all these unserviced areas.
But even as this imperative is met, the pollution plan must begin to trap, intercept and treat all sewage, regardless of colour, caste or creed. This sewage from drains can be transported to the underutilised treatment facilities.
secondly, sewage must be treated as close to the source as possible. This will minimise cost of first transporting sewage for treatment and the conveyance of the treated effluent.
The key pollution lesson is that treated effluent must be reused and recycled and not allowed to be mixed with the untreated in drains. This will require governments to work on a plan to reuse the treated effluents of each plant.
thirdly, as less and less of what is treated makes its way to the drain, the drain with its segregated waste can then be treated at the point of disposal into the river. In other words, what is finally left in the drain must be treated as close to the river, so that the treated effluent is used to dilute the river water and not pollute it.
But all this is only possible if we monitor treated waste and strictly enforce standards. Otherwise, we cannot promote reuse.
The end of the story of Delhi's Yamuna is the beginning of the excreta tales of India. Of more pollution, more sewage. Where people use water, flush it and forget it. Only to drown in their own excreta. Only to degrade their waterways. And only to create more disease and death. If we want a happy ending we must make a new beginning: build a society that learns about its waste so that it can minimise want. A water prudent society. A river worshipping society. Not in the ritual sense, but in the true sense.
- Order of the National Green Tribunal on Platinum AAC Blocks, Daman Diu & Dadra Nagar Haveli, 19/01/2021
- Order of the National Green Tribunal regarding illegal constructions over land for park and open spaces, Meerut, Uttar Pradesh, 19/01/2021
- Order of the National Green Tribunal regarding regulatory regime to check acidic activities in testing of gold, 19/01/2021
- Joint Committee report on pollution of Buckingham Canal, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, 19/01/2021
- The Global Risks Report 2021
- The State of Economic Inclusion Report 2021